STITES ANCESTRY


Charlotte


Charlotte and Gladys
The mother of Charlotte Louise Retherford Donald was Mary Gladys Stites Retherford. Gladys’ Stites ancestry has been traced back a considerable ways and her kin include some historically significant persons. While accounts vary, and evidence is thin, an immigrating ancestor appears to have been Dr. John Stites (b. 1595?). He was reportedly a physician who sided with Cromwell and then found it wise to leave for America prior to the 1660 restoration of the monarchy.
Simeon, Nettie Belle Stites and family
(Gladys is on far right top)

Stites family: Annette Isabelle "Nettie Belle" Buckler
and Simeon Stites in front.
Gladys in the back row, far right.
In the 1841 census of England, Stites people numbered under 100, and were widely dispersed in the south of England. By 1881, only a handful of Stites people lived in Kent. By contrast, the U.S. 1790 census showed 15 Stites people, and by 1880 there were nearly 1300 Stites-surnamed people. It is possible that this is a single-origin, or limited number of origins, surname. A small existing Stites surname yDNA project may eventually prove interesting.  A Stites 37 STR marker yDNA sample at www.ysearch.org ID #TKQKY was in Haplogroup R1a1a; the ancestor was William Stites, born about 1884 in Arkansas. Further SNP (Single Nucleotide Polymorphism) testing on this sample to determine subclade would undoubtedly be very interesting.

Major Benjamin Stites Jr. (1746-1804) helped found the city of Cincinnati. His ancestor Richard (son of Dr. John) was also the ancestor of Gladys. Benjamin Stites may have had close encounters with Gary’s McCreary ancestors, both in Redstone, Fayette County, Pennsylvania, and in southwest Ohio.

Gladys Stites Retherford’s paternal grandmother was Anna Beckett. Information is inconsistent on Anna’s dates and place of origin (Ireland or England?). Family history says that she came to America with plans to be a nun. However, when she was a teenager she rode her horse past the land (we have a picture of the house and land) of older bachelor Jacob Stites (b. 1805, Cape May County, New Jersey) and decided that she would marry that man. They married in 1856 in Butler County, Ohio, not far from Gary Muffley’s McCreary ancestors (see McCreary Blog). Jacob’s and Anna’s 4 kids were born in Ohio, and later they lived in Coles County, Illinois. After the kids were raised and her husband died, Anna went alone to Oklahoma to do the homesteading run of 1889. The thousands of people participating in the “run” started about 3 miles north of current Stillwater. Anne and Gary Muffley somewhat followed the route Anna might have taken, for about 10 miles. Anna set up farming west of Mehan, near Stillwater Creek and Union Road. This was quite close to the future land of Jesse Retherford Jr. Anna farmed there alone for about 3 years, became ill, and returned to Illinois. Later, her son Simeon Stites and his wife Nettie Belle Buckler Stites made the 3 weeks trip in a covered wagon from Coles County Illinois to settle on Anna’s land in Oklahoma. Anna may have had close encounters with the Dalton-Doolin Gang, whose biggest battle with lawmen occurred in Ingalls in 1893 just a few miles away from her land. Rough territory even for that plucky lady.  

Annette Isabelle “Nettie Belle” Buckler eloped with Simeon Stephen Stites. She wore her wedding dress under other clothing and secretly left town (just like Gary’s Grandma Edna Jagger Muffley; see the Muffley Blog). Nettie and Simeon took a train in the night to the next county, sat until morning at the train station at Marshall, Clark County, Illinois, and married on November 11, 1885.

Nettie Belle Buckler Stites’ Grandpa William Goodrum Buckler enlisted in Company H (Yeats’ Sharpshooters), 64th Illinois Volunteers Regiment. He was killed in battle at Marietta, Georgia, October 10, 1864. William’s Grandpa Robert Buckler was reportedly born in 1745 in Dublin, Ireland, and migrated to Kentucky. Robert’s father Steven Buckler (b. 1721, Dublin) was reportedly the master of the schooner “The Hawks”. This Buckler line appears to be connected with www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kyrobert/family/bucklerfamily.html 

Simeon and Nettie Belle Buckler Stites had 10 kids. Mary Gladys Stites was born in 1901 at Ripley, Oklahoma Territory.